Castles and Cuisine: The Ultimate Luxury Road Trip Through Bavaria and Rothenburg

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from purchases at no extra cost to you, which helps our travel content.

There's something undeniably magical about Bavaria that captivates even the most seasoned travelers. Perhaps it's the way morning mist clings to medieval castle turrets, or how the Alps frame picture-perfect villages that seem plucked from storybooks. Having explored over 30 countries, I've developed a particular fondness for journeys that blend architectural wonders with cultural immersion—and nowhere delivers this combination quite like southern Germany. Last summer, I embarked on what I can only describe as the quintessential luxury road trip: two weeks winding through Bavaria's countryside, from the gingerbread-perfect streets of Rothenburg ob der Tauber to the majestic castles that inspired Walt Disney himself. This wasn't just travel; it was time travel wrapped in five-star comfort, where each day delivered both educational discoveries and indulgent pleasures. Join me as I share the definitive guide to experiencing Bavaria's treasures in sophisticated style, complete with hidden gems that most tourists miss and the exclusive experiences that transformed this journey from merely memorable to utterly unforgettable.

Planning Your Bavarian Luxury Escape

When orchestrating a Bavarian road trip that balances historic immersion with modern luxury, timing and transportation become your first crucial decisions. I chose late June for my adventure—a sweet spot before July's tourist crowds but warm enough for convertible driving with endless daylight hours for exploration.

For a journey of this caliber, your vehicle becomes more than transportation; it's part of the experience itself. After considerable research, I arranged a luxury car rental through Sixt's premium collection. The Mercedes E-Class Cabriolet proved perfect for Bavaria's winding country roads—powerful enough for autobahn stretches yet comfortable for full-day drives. The convertible top allowed me to fully immerse in the landscape, feeling the temperature shift as we climbed into Alpine regions and catching the scent of wildflowers along countryside routes.

Rather than the typical Munich starting point, I recommend beginning in Frankfurt, which offers excellent international connections and positions you perfectly for a first stop in Rothenburg. From there, create a clockwise loop through Würzburg, Nuremberg, Regensburg, and down to Berchtesgaden before circling back toward Munich and the famous Romantic Road.

While spontaneity has its charms, Bavaria's most exceptional accommodations require advance planning. I secured reservations three months ahead, which granted access to castle hotels that often book solid six months out. For Michelin-starred restaurants, particularly in smaller towns like Baiersbronn (a culinary mecca hidden in the Black Forest), I made dinner reservations simultaneously with hotel bookings.

My meticulously planned itinerary still allowed for serendipity—I built in two 'floating days' with no fixed plans, which ended up being devoted to an unexpected invitation to a private vineyard tour and an impromptu detour to Lake Constance when weather conditions were exceptionally clear.

Luxury convertible car on winding Bavarian country road with Alps in background
The freedom of exploring Bavaria's countryside roads with the top down creates an immersive sensory experience unlike any other mode of travel.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Book castle hotels at least 4-6 months in advance for summer travel
  • Request a printed map from your rental company—GPS occasionally fails in remote castle locations
  • Consider the Mercedes-Benz Museum in Stuttgart as your first stop if starting from Frankfurt

Rothenburg ob der Tauber: Medieval Luxury in Germany's Most Preserved Town

Arriving in Rothenburg ob der Tauber feels like stepping directly into a medieval painting. The town's perfectly preserved 13th-century walls encircle a maze of cobblestone streets and half-timbered houses so picturesque they seem almost artificial—yet every weathered stone tells authentic stories spanning seven centuries.

While most visitors experience Rothenburg as day-trippers, the true luxury lies in overnight immersion when tour buses depart. I checked into Hotel Herrnschlösschen, a meticulously restored 11th-century manor house offering just seven unique suites. My Deluxe Garden Suite featured original exposed beams contrasted with heated marble floors and a freestanding copper bathtub positioned perfectly beneath a skylight for stargazing. The hotel's exclusivity means personalized service—the proprietor herself conducted my check-in over house-made elderflower spritzers in the private garden.

Rothenburg reveals its true character after 5pm. I arranged a private twilight tour with historian Dr. Harald Schmidt, who unlocked normally inaccessible tower rooms and shared stories of the town's miraculous survival during World War II. The evening concluded with privileged access to the Night Watchman's Tower, where we sipped local Franconian wine while watching sunset paint the medieval rooftops gold.

For dining, avoid the tourist-oriented restaurants on Marktplatz. Instead, I discovered culinary excellence at Zur Höll (translated as "To Hell"), housed in the town's oldest building (circa 900 AD). Their seasonal tasting menu showcases modern interpretations of Franconian classics—the wild mushroom spätzle with black truffle was transcendent. Request the corner table in the original stone cellar for the most atmospheric experience.

Morning offers a rare opportunity to experience Rothenburg's empty streets. I rose at dawn for a photography walk along the complete 1.5-mile medieval wall circuit, capturing the town in perfect light without another soul in sight. My camera stabilizer proved invaluable for smooth video while walking the uneven ancient pathways.

Before departing, visit master confectioner Georg Friedel's workshop for a private demonstration of Schneeballen ("snowballs")—Rothenburg's signature pastry dating to the 1400s. Unlike the mass-produced versions in tourist shops, Friedel creates limited batches using techniques passed down seven generations, with flavors like saffron-orange that aren't available elsewhere.

Empty medieval streets of Rothenburg ob der Tauber at dawn with golden light
The privilege of experiencing Rothenburg's medieval perfection at dawn, before the day visitors arrive, is worth the early alarm.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Book the Medieval Crime Museum for a private after-hours tour (€150 but worth every penny)
  • Request the Käthe Wohlfahrt Christmas store's VIP shopping experience to access their private collection room
  • The best photography vantage point is from the Castle Garden at the northern edge of town, especially at sunrise

Castle Hopping: From Neuschwanstein to Hidden Gems

No Bavarian luxury itinerary would be complete without experiencing the region's legendary castles, though the true connoisseur knows that avoiding crowds while accessing exclusive areas requires strategic planning. While Neuschwanstein Castle justifiably tops most travelers' lists, my approach revealed dimensions of these architectural treasures that most visitors never encounter.

For Neuschwanstein, I bypassed the standard tour by arranging a "King Ludwig II Exclusive" experience through the Bavarian Castle Administration (requiring booking 3+ months ahead). This grants early entry at 7:30am—a full hour before public admission—and includes normally restricted areas like Ludwig's private study and the unfinished Byzantine Throne Room. Our small group of six enjoyed the ethereal morning light filtering through stained glass windows without the echo of other tours. The experience culminated in a private breakfast on the castle terrace overlooking Alpsee Lake—a setting normally inaccessible to visitors.

While Neuschwanstein dazzles with fairy-tale grandeur, I found equal enchantment in lesser-known Bavarian castles. Schloss Linderhof, Ludwig's smallest palace, offers the most intimate glimpse into the king's personality. I arranged a special curator's tour focusing on the technological innovations hidden within its Rococo splendor—including the mechanical rising dining table that allowed Ludwig to dine without servants present. The Venus Grotto, Ludwig's artificial candlelit cave with heated wave machine and rainbow lighting effects, recently reopened after extensive restoration.

For the ultimate castle experience, I spent two nights at Schloss Elmau, a historic castle transformed into a cultural hideaway and luxury spa resort. Nestled in a private Alpine valley near the Austrian border, this property hosted the G7 Summit and offers unparalleled amenities—six separate spa facilities, a concert hall featuring world-class musicians, and a library housing 20,000+ volumes. My Deluxe Junior Suite in the Retreat building featured panoramic mountain views and private balcony hot tubs. The property's six restaurants include the Michelin-starred Luce d'Oro, where Chef Christoph Rainer creates Alpine-Mediterranean fusion that rivals any dining experience in Germany.

My most memorable castle discovery came through a local connection—Schloss Egg, a 12th-century fortress in Lower Bavaria that remains family-owned and largely unknown to international travelers. Count von Deym offers overnight stays in authentically furnished medieval chambers (with discreetly modernized bathrooms) and hosts intimate falconry demonstrations in the castle courtyard. Evening brings candlelit dinners in the knights' hall, featuring game from the castle's hunting grounds paired with wines from their private cellar.

For capturing these majestic structures, my wide angle lens proved essential, particularly for interior architecture shots where standard lenses simply cannot capture the grandeur of ceremonial halls and staircases.

Exclusive breakfast setup on private castle terrace overlooking Bavarian Alps
The privilege of private access: breakfast on Neuschwanstein's normally restricted terrace offers unparalleled views across the Bavarian countryside.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Book the first Neuschwanstein tour of the day (7:30am) to photograph the castle without crowds
  • Request the Tower Room when staying at Schloss Elmau for the most spectacular mountain views
  • Visit Hohenschwangau Castle (adjacent to Neuschwanstein) in late afternoon when most tourists have departed

Culinary Bavaria: Beyond Bratwurst and Beer

Bavaria's gastronomic landscape extends far beyond the stereotypical pretzels and sausages that dominate tourist menus. My culinary exploration revealed a sophisticated regional cuisine undergoing a remarkable renaissance, with talented chefs reinterpreting traditional flavors through modern techniques while maintaining deep connections to local producers.

My epicurean journey began at Restaurant Überfahrt in Rottach-Egern on Tegernsee Lake. Chef Christian Jürgens has maintained three Michelin stars by transforming humble Bavarian ingredients into artistic expressions. His signature "Potato Foam, Truffle and Leek" elevates the humble tuber into something transcendent—a dish that pays homage to regional farming traditions while employing cutting-edge culinary science. The restaurant's lakeside setting adds natural drama to the dining experience, with floor-to-ceiling windows framing Alpine reflections on the water's surface.

For those seeking to understand Bavarian cuisine's foundations, I recommend the immersive cooking workshop at Wernberg Castle. This 13th-century fortress houses both a luxury hotel and a culinary academy where I spent a half-day learning traditional techniques from Chef Thomas Kellermann. We foraged wild herbs from the castle grounds, then prepared updated versions of historical dishes like Bayrisch Creme and venison with lingonberry sauce. The experience concluded with a private lunch in the herb garden, pairing our creations with Franconian wines rarely exported beyond Germany.

The vineyards of Franconia (northern Bavaria) remain one of Germany's best-kept wine secrets. I arranged a private tasting at Bürgerspital estate in Würzburg, where eight centuries of winemaking tradition produce exceptional Silvaner and Riesling varieties. Their signature Bocksbeutel bottles—distinctive flat, round flasks—contain some of Germany's most underrated wines. The VIP tasting includes access to their historic cellar housing barrels dating to 1540.

For a truly unforgettable dining experience, I ventured to the tiny Black Forest village of Baiersbronn, which improbably boasts eight Michelin stars within a four-mile radius. At Bareiss Restaurant, Chef Claus-Peter Lumpp creates refined Black Forest cuisine in an elegant dining room where service approaches performance art. The sommelier introduced me to exceptional regional wines through a custom pairing that included rare bottles from their 20,000-bottle cellar.

No culinary exploration would be complete without acknowledging Bavaria's brewing heritage. Rather than tourist-oriented beer halls, I sought authentic experiences like the private brewery tour at Kloster Andechs, a working monastery where monks have brewed beer since 1455 using recipes unchanged for centuries. The brewery's VIP experience includes tasting directly from aging tanks normally inaccessible to visitors.

To capture these culinary masterpieces, I relied on my portable lighting kit which provided perfect illumination for food photography without disturbing other diners—essential for documenting these ephemeral artistic creations.

Elegant Bavarian fine dining experience with artistic food presentation and mountain view
At Restaurant Überfahrt, each course arrives as both culinary masterpiece and artistic statement—this reinterpreted Bavarian classic showcases local ingredients through modern technique.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Request the chef's table at Restaurant Überfahrt for an interactive dining experience with direct kitchen access
  • Book vineyard tours in Franconia for weekdays when winemakers themselves often conduct tastings
  • When dining at Michelin-starred restaurants, request half-portions of more courses rather than full portions to experience greater variety

Hidden Bavaria: Secret Spots Beyond the Tourist Trail

While Bavaria's marquee attractions deserve their fame, my most treasured memories come from discoveries made far from the well-trodden tourist paths. These hidden corners reveal Bavaria's authentic character and offer luxury experiences without crowds—often at surprisingly reasonable prices.

The medieval town of Meersburg on Lake Constance (Bodensee) offers a sophisticated alternative to more frequented lakeside destinations. I stayed at Schlosshotel Meersburg, occupying a 17th-century baroque palace where each room features original architectural elements and lake views. The hotel's private dock allowed for a sunset cruise aboard a restored 1920s wooden yacht, complete with champagne service and a personal guide explaining the region's unique geography where Germany, Austria, and Switzerland converge.

Near the Czech border lies Passau, known as the "City of Three Rivers" where the Danube, Inn, and Ilz converge. While day-trippers visit briefly before river cruises, I discovered the city's true charm by staying at Hotel Residenz Passau, housed in a former prince-bishop's palace. Their concierge arranged early morning access to St. Stephen's Cathedral before public hours, allowing me to experience a short private concert on the world's largest cathedral organ—17,974 pipes filling the baroque space with thunderous sound.

For wellness enthusiasts, bypass the famous Baden-Baden spas for Bad Reichenhall, a historic salt-mining town near Berchtesgaden. The RupertusTherme combines natural alpine salt springs with sophisticated treatments in a modernist glass structure overlooking the Alps. I indulged in their "Bavarian Royal Treatment"—a three-hour experience including a salt peeling using locally mined crystals, alpine herb compress massage, and flotation in a private salt-concentration pool mimicking the Dead Sea.

My most unexpected discovery came in the Altmühltal Nature Park, where limestone cliffs hide Prunn Castle, an 11th-century fortress containing one of Germany's most significant literary treasures. A private tour arranged through the Bavarian Castle Administration revealed the original manuscript of the Nibelungenlied (Germany's equivalent to Beowulf) discovered hidden in the castle walls during renovations. The curator allowed me to view manuscript pages not displayed to general visitors.

For transportation between these hidden gems, I occasionally supplemented my rental car with Bavaria's exceptional rail system. The travel backpack proved perfect for overnight detours, combining sophisticated styling with practical organization for camera gear, electronics, and a change of clothes.

These lesser-known destinations offer what luxury travelers value most—authenticity, exclusivity, and meaningful connection to place. They provide breathing room from Bavaria's more crowded highlights while revealing dimensions of regional culture inaccessible to those following standard itineraries.

Vintage wooden yacht on Lake Constance with medieval Meersburg town and castle in background
Exploring Lake Constance aboard a restored vintage yacht offers perspectives of medieval Meersburg impossible to appreciate from land.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Request the Tower Suite at Schlosshotel Meersburg for 270-degree lake views and original baroque ceiling frescoes
  • Visit Prunn Castle on Thursdays when their manuscript expert provides specialized tours by appointment
  • In Bad Reichenhall, the AlpenSole springs are less crowded before 10am and after 6pm

Accommodation Gems: Historic Luxury with Modern Comforts

Bavaria excels in transforming historical properties into accommodations that honor architectural heritage while providing contemporary luxury. My carefully curated selection of properties created a narrative thread through different eras of Bavarian history, from medieval fortress to baroque palace to modernist mountain retreat.

For those seeking authentic castle accommodations, Burg Colmberg delivers a genuine medieval experience without sacrificing comfort. Perched dramatically atop a hill near Rothenburg, this 1000-year-old fortress features original stone spiral staircases, massive wooden beams, and arrow-slit windows—yet rooms include heated bathroom floors and custom-made mattresses. Request the Comtesse Suite in the tower, featuring a canopied bed and panoramic countryside views. The property's intimate restaurant serves game from the castle's hunting grounds and vegetables from their kitchen garden. Most memorably, guests can arrange private access to the castle ramparts after closing hours—I enjoyed a nightcap while watching stars emerge over the Franconian countryside.

For baroque elegance, Hotel Vier Jahreszeiten Kempinski in Munich represents Bavarian luxury at its most refined. This historic grand hotel on Maximilianstrasse balances old-world sophistication with contemporary amenities. My Deluxe Suite featured original stucco ceilings, silk wall coverings, and marble bathrooms with both rainfall showers and soaking tubs. The property's Schwarzreiter Restaurant holds a Michelin star for its "young Bavarian cuisine"—traditional recipes reimagined with modern technique. The true highlight, however, was the hotel's rooftop spa, offering panoramic views across Munich's historic center while enjoying treatments incorporating Bavarian forest botanicals.

In the Alpine region, Schloss Elmau has pioneered a new category of luxury—the cultural hideaway. This sprawling property hosts over 200 concerts and literary events annually in its own concert hall, attracting world-class musicians who often stay for mini-residencies. Accommodations are divided between the historic castle and the newer Retreat building, where my suite featured floor-to-ceiling windows framing mountain vistas and a private terrace with hot tub. With six separate spa facilities and six distinct restaurants, guests could easily spend a week without leaving the property—though the spectacular hiking directly from the grounds makes exploration irresistible.

For those seeking luxury in smaller towns, I discovered Hotel Goldener Hirsch in Rothenburg, where the 15th-century building houses just eight uniquely designed rooms. My accommodations featured original painted wooden ceilings, window seats built into the medieval walls, and bathrooms ingeniously incorporated into the historic structure. The owners—descendants of the family who built the property—provide personalized service impossible at larger establishments.

Navigating Bavaria's historic properties often means adapting to architectural quirks. My travel power strip proved essential in centuries-old buildings where outlets are scarce. The combination of USB-C power delivery and standard plugs kept all my devices charged despite medieval wiring systems never designed for modern travelers' needs.

Luxury suite in Bavarian castle hotel with four-poster bed and panoramic countryside views
My suite at Burg Colmberg seamlessly blended medieval architecture with subtle modern luxuries—note the heated floors beneath centuries-old stone.

💡 Pro Tips

  • Request rooms facing interior courtyards in historic properties for the quietest experience
  • Book castle accommodations for minimum two-night stays—these properties reveal their character slowly
  • When staying at Schloss Elmau, reserve spa treatments and restaurant tables simultaneously with your room booking

Final Thoughts

As my Mercedes wound its way back toward Munich on the final day of this Bavarian odyssey, I found myself already mentally planning a return journey. Bavaria's particular magic lies in its seamless blending of past and present—where thousand-year-old castles house world-class spas, and medieval town squares conceal Michelin-starred dining rooms. The luxury here isn't about ostentation but rather privileged access to experiences of exceptional quality and cultural significance.

What makes Bavaria truly special for the discerning traveler is this layered richness: architectural wonders that educate as they awe, culinary traditions that honor heritage while embracing innovation, and landscapes that frame human achievements within natural splendor. Whether you're sipping coffee on a private castle terrace as morning mist rises from the valley below, or savoring a contemporary interpretation of ancient recipes while dining in a vaulted medieval cellar, Bavaria rewards those who seek deeper connection with transformative experiences.

I invite you to create your own Bavarian narrative—one where luxury serves not as an end but as a means to access authentic cultural treasures. The memories you'll cherish longest won't be thread counts or amenities but rather those moments of privileged insight: a curator sharing stories of a painting never mentioned in guidebooks, a winemaker opening bottles reserved for family, or the perfect solitude of ancient ramparts at sunrise.

✨ Key Takeaways

  • Bavaria rewards travelers who venture beyond famous destinations to discover authentic experiences in lesser-known towns
  • Luxury castle accommodations require booking 4-6 months in advance, especially for summer travel
  • Private guided experiences offer access to restricted areas in major attractions, justifying their premium cost

📋 Practical Information

Best Time to Visit

Late May through June or September through early October

Budget Estimate

$10,000-15,000 per person for 2 weeks (luxury accommodations, private guides, fine dining)

Recommended Duration

12-14 days minimum to experience the region properly

Difficulty Level

Moderate - Driving Required With Some Navigation Of Medieval Towns With Cobblestone Streets And Steps

Comments

Comments are moderated and will appear after approval.
backpackmaster

backpackmaster

Is it doable without renting a car? Public transport options?

nomadnomad

nomadnomad

We did it by train! The Bayern Ticket is amazing value. You miss some flexibility but trains to Rothenburg and Füssen (for Neuschwanstein) run regularly. Just need to plan your days carefully!

Christopher Morris

Christopher Morris

Excellent write-up, Nova. Having done this route several times for both pleasure and business, I'd add that Hohenschwangau Castle (right next to Neuschwanstein) is actually more interesting historically, though less photogenic. For those driving this route, I recommend using the BMW Road Trip App which has excellent offline mapping for the rural Bavarian roads where signal can be spotty. The section on culinary experiences was spot on - Käsespätzle in Bavaria is unlike anywhere else in Germany. Did you get a chance to visit Würzburg on your route? The Residenz there is UNESCO listed and quite spectacular.

Nova Rice

Nova Rice

Thanks Christopher! You're absolutely right about Hohenschwangau - I found the interior tour much more intimate and informative. I did pass through Würzburg but didn't have enough time for the Residenz - definitely on my list for next time!

Amy Brown

Amy Brown

Nova, your post took me right back to my own Bavarian adventure last year! There's something about the light in Rothenburg at sunset that seems almost engineered for photographers, isn't there? My husband and I spent three nights there and discovered a tiny wine cellar called Glocke that serves regional wines paired with local cheeses - absolute heaven after a day of exploring. For anyone planning this trip, I'd add Bamberg to your itinerary if you can spare an extra day. It's another perfectly preserved medieval town but with a completely different character than Rothenburg - famous for its smoked beer and stunning town hall built on a bridge. The drive between the two takes you through some gorgeous countryside dotted with smaller castles that don't make the guidebooks but are worth stopping for. Wonderful to see someone else appreciating the quieter luxuries of Bavaria beyond the obvious attractions!

nomadnomad

nomadnomad

Just got back from Bavaria last month and your post brought back so many memories! We also stayed at that boutique hotel in Rothenburg (Hotel Gotisches Haus) and the breakfast was incredible. One tip for anyone going - don't miss the Night Watchman's Tour in Rothenburg. It was honestly the highlight of our trip and gives you such interesting history about the town. Also, we found this amazing little restaurant called Baumeisterhaus that wasn't in any of the guidebooks but had the best schnitzel I've ever tasted!

backpackmaster

backpackmaster

Thanks for the restaurant tip! Adding it to my list!

oceandiver

oceandiver

OMG those photos of Neuschwanstein are STUNNING! Did you really get that view without crowds? I'm so jealous! We're heading there next spring and I'm definitely renting a car now after reading this.

photoone

photoone

Beautiful post! What time of year did you visit? I'm planning a trip and wondering when the castles are least crowded.

Nova Rice

Nova Rice

Thanks! I visited in late September/early October - perfect weather and fewer tourists than summer. The castles still get busy but early mornings (first entry) are magical!

photoone

photoone

Perfect, thanks! Fall sounds ideal for those misty morning castle views you described.

Bella Harper

Bella Harper

Nova, your article brought back wonderful memories of my trip to Bavaria last year! I'd add that for those wanting to experience Neuschwanstein without the crowds, staying overnight in Hohenschwangau is the move. We were able to visit right at opening time before the tour buses arrived. For food lovers, I'd recommend stopping at small village gasthäuser rather than tourist spots in Rothenburg - the Franconian wine region has some incredible local specialties. And that medieval crime museum in Rothenburg you mentioned? Absolutely fascinating and macabre! My husband still talks about the shame masks. Looking forward to your next adventure!

Nova Rice

Nova Rice

Great tip about staying in Hohenschwangau, Bella! Those early morning castle views without crowds are magical. And yes, those shame masks were quite something, weren't they?

mountainmate

mountainmate

If anyone's planning this trip, don't miss Würzburg on the way to Rothenburg - the Residence palace there is UNESCO-listed and the ceiling fresco will blow your mind. Also, we found driving in Bavaria super easy compared to other parts of Europe. Roads are well-maintained and signposted.

luckyguide

luckyguide

Those photos of Rothenburg!!! 😍 I'm going in June and can't wait to walk the wall! Did you do the Night Watchman's Tour?

Nova Rice

Nova Rice

Yes! The Night Watchman's Tour is absolutely worth it - entertaining and informative. Book in advance if you can, it gets crowded in summer!

Jean Shaw

Jean Shaw

Nova, your description of morning mist clinging to castle turrets took me right back to my own Bavarian adventure last autumn! I'd add Burg Eltz to anyone's itinerary - it's technically in Rhineland-Palatinate but worth the detour. The guided tour there was exceptional. And for anyone planning this trip, I found having a good guidebook invaluable for those countryside drives where mobile reception gets spotty. I used Rick Steves which had excellent walking tours for Rothenburg especially. Your culinary section has me craving Käsespätzle again!

luckyguide

luckyguide

Burg Eltz is GORGEOUS! We went there last year and it felt like stepping into a fairytale. Definitely worth the side trip!

Showing 1 of 4 comment pages